Faire une nouvelle recherche
Make a new search
Lancer la recherche

Titre du document / Document title

A facilitative versus directive approach in training clinical skills? Investigating students’ clinical performance and perceptions

Auteur(s) / Author(s)

Berghmans Inneke (1) ; Druine Nathalie (2) ; Dochy Filip (1) ; Struyven Katrien (3) ;

Affiliation(s) du ou des auteurs / Author(s) Affiliation(s)

(1) Centre for Research on Professional Learning & Development, Corporate Training and Lifelong Learning, University of Leuven, 3000, Leuven, Belgium
(2) Medical Education Unit, Faculty of Medicine, University of Leuven, Leuven, Belgium
(3) Educational Sciences Department, Vrije Universiteit Brussel (VUB), Brussels, Belgium

Résumé / Abstract

Over the years, many medical school curricula have started implementing diverse student-centred teaching and learning methodologies. Previous studies, however, have indicated that students prefer more traditional and directive methodologies instead, raising questions on which training approach should be advocated. This study contrasts the effects of a student-centred (i.e. facilitative) training approach on students’ clinical skills learning with students’ perceptions. More specifically, a quasi-experimental study was set up in which students experienced either a directive or facilitative training approach. Data were collected by means of an OSCE on the one hand, and a questionnaire on students’ perceptions of the training sessions, and two open-ended questions about students’ likes and dislikes on the other hand. While no general differences were found in terms of clinical knowledge and understanding, and actual clinical performance, an interaction between students’ course-specific prior knowledge and the training approach was found. Especially students with low levels of knowledge benefited more from the facilitative training approach in terms of clinical knowledge, while highly knowledgeable students experienced a negative effect of this training approach. Moreover, students’ perceptions revealed that facilitative-trained students reported more deep-level learning, while the directive training approach turned out to score higher in terms of quality and perceived effects.

Revue / Journal Title

Perspectives on medical education    ISSN  2212-277X 

Source / Source

2012, vol. 1, no3, pp. 104-118 [15 page(s) (article)]

Langue / Language


Editeur / Publisher

Springer, Heidelberg, ALLEMAGNE  (2012) (Revue)

Mots-clés d'auteur / Author Keywords

Peer Assisted Learning


Clinical skills training


Clinical learning outcomes


Students’ perceptions


Localisation / Location


the authors, 2012
Nº notice refdoc (ud4) : 26219206

Faire une nouvelle recherche
Make a new search
Lancer la recherche